Balancer fork’s 6 million BAL ask could cut holders’ redemption value

MAXYZ, a group of former Balancer contributors, is asking for up to 6 million currently non-circulating BAL to seed a successor protocol. If the granted tokens reach other eligible holders before Balancer's proposed wind-down redemption snapshot, the same treasury would be divided among more BAL. In exchange, MAXYZ proposes a contingent allocation from a future fork to the Balancer treasury, an asset with no realized value today.The fork proposal, posted Sept. 20 and expanded in a Sept. 23 FAQ, sits beside a separate wind-down plan to let BAL holders burn their tokens for a pro rata share of the DAO's remaining assets. Neither forum proposal by itself transfers tokens, changes pool operations or gives the fork rights to code. The financial question for an old holder is how much of the grant would become redeemable, and whether a possible future stake in the fork compensates for a smaller share of the old treasury.What six million BAL would changeMAXYZ identifies about 3.5 million BAL in the treasury, 1.6 million in a Balancer Labs fundraise safe and 928,000 in a Labs team safe as its proposed seed. Its Sept. 23 FAQ proposes taking half the grant upfront and the rest, up to the same...