1 hour ago
1
Germany had never lost a World Cup penalty shootout. Six attempts across tournament history, six victories. That streak, one of the most ironclad records in international football, died on June 29, 2026, in the most agonizing way imaginable.
Paraguay, ranked 34th in the world, knocked out the four-time champions 4-3 on penalties after the two sides drew 1-1 through 120 minutes. The decisive moment came when Jonathan Tah, a center-back with zero senior penalty kicks to his name, launched the ball over the crossbar in sudden death. It was the kind of miss that doesn’t just end a match. It ends an era.
How it unraveled
Manuel Neuer, 40 years old, did everything he could to keep his side alive. He saved two Paraguayan penalties during the shootout, including a stop from Fabián Balbuena.
But Germany missed three of their penalties. Kai Havertz missed. Woltemade missed. And then came the sixth round, the sudden death portion, where things got truly uncomfortable.
After Neuer’s save had given Germany a lifeline, the team needed someone to step up and take the next kick. Nobody rushed to the spot. There was hesitation, the kind you can feel through a television screen.
Jonathan Tah volunteered. A defender. A player who had never taken a senior penalty in his career. Not once. Not in the Bundesliga, not in the Champions League, not in any international fixture. He walked to the spot and sent the ball sailing over the crossbar.
Paraguay’s José Canale then stepped up and buried the winning penalty, sending his country into delirium and Germany into one of its darkest World Cup moments.
The weight of a perfect record
Germany had won all six of their previous World Cup penalty shootouts. That record wasn’t just a statistical curiosity. It was part of German football identity — the stereotype of German efficiency, of composure under pressure. Penalty shootouts were supposed to be Germany’s domain.
And it ended not with a narrow miss or a brilliant save, but with a center-back skying the ball over the goal entirely.
Paraguay, ranked 34th in the world heading into the tournament, were heavy underdogs. Drawing Germany through 120 minutes required extraordinary defensive organization and composure. Winning the shootout 4-3 required nerve that, on the night, the South Americans had in greater supply than their European opponents.
What this means for German football
The hesitation before Tah’s penalty is the detail that will be dissected endlessly. In a well-prepared squad, the penalty order is typically settled before the shootout begins. The fact that there was visible uncertainty suggests either the preparation wasn’t thorough enough or the designated takers simply refused when the moment arrived.
At 40, Neuer delivered two saves in the shootout. Three missed penalties out of six attempts is a 50% conversion rate. In World Cup shootouts, teams typically need to convert at least 70-75% of their kicks to have any realistic chance of advancing. Germany didn’t come close to that threshold.
José Canale, the man who scored the winner, will never buy his own dinner in Asunción again.
Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.
English (US) · 